By Jonny Kipper
June 12 2025
Let me tell you about the time I accidentally created one of the most laughable transfer rumours you're likely to find, a rumour so nonsensical that it perfectly sums up the summer transfer window. And when I say I created it, I literally mean the manager of the club in question was asked about it in a press conference. This wasn't a silly little Twitter rumour; it generated interest in the world of football and at one point this player was even odds-on to join the club, according to Bet Victor. It may not have been odds-on actually, but he was definitely favourite to join this particular team - and all because of me.
I used to write about football and you can imagine the summer transfer window was our busy time. And we were judged - and kind of paid - depending on how many hits and clicks our articles got. I was pretty good at crafting headlines and if you had a really good headline for an opinion article that made no sense, you'd write it up anyway because, again, you're looking for people to click into it. All you needed was something very tenuous to link it together.
Like if I was still doing the job now I'd probably write an opinion article on why Arsenal should sign Kevin De Bruyne just because of the Manchester City connection and the fact you could headline it like this: 'Arsenal can now sign star who once pushed Mikel Arteta', in reference to the fact he shoved Arteta at the Emirates a few years ago.
This headline would bang in a major way. A lot of people would click into it. The 'can now' part implies it could actually happen, without breaking News Now rules, and there's a million little language tricks like that you learn to embellish headlines, to make opinion articles look a lot more credible from the headline end.
Back in 2016, I wrote an OPINION article about why Rangers should sign Robin van Persie. I can't find said article any longer so I can't remember what tenuous link I used to connect him and Rangers, but I think he was released by Fenerbahce at the time and Rangers, after being promoted back to the top tier of Scottish football, were sort of flying high again and there was a bit of buzz about them. When asked about it in a press conference, then-Rangers manager Mark Warburton said: "These stories do entertain me. I don't know where these things come from. I'm sure someone is laughing somewhere."
I know exactly how it started.
So I wrote my OPINION piece on why Rangers should sign Robin van Persie. Because I had a good headline, it did good numbers and eventually a Turkish website [I think Fanatik or one of these big Turkish sites] stumbled across it and due to the language barrier, interpreted my OPINION article as a transfer exclusive. And in the world of online football journalism, the ratio of sites that attribute sources in transfer articles to those that don't is literally 1:20. Most do not link to the original source. Fanatik or whoever it was did not link to my article. They ran it as their own transfer report. And then The Daily Record or The Scottish Sun see their copy and go, 'F*ck me look what's been reported in Turkey. Van Persie to Rangers! Then they pick it up. Then the bookmakers create a market for it. And then voila, it's a rumour. That's when the manager - Mark Warburton - gets asked about it in a press conference.
And this perfectly typifies the carnage and tail-chasing that is the summer transfer window.
What a lot of football fans don't realise about this time of the year is that transfer business is a business. Not just for the clubs in the Premier League, who splashed a combined £2.08 billion on transfers last summer, but it's also massive business for the endless amount of media outlets reporting on the transfers.
There is an insatiable demand for transfer-related content and that's why you see such a rich supply of it during the summer. It's because revenue goes through the roof for these websites from May to September, which is important because the hits plummet during international breaks and there's three of these relatively close together after the window shuts.
From a business perspective, you have to squeeze every drop of revenue out of the summer months to weather the storm that comes in September, October and November, before the rumour mill starts motoring again in time for January.
Again, it's a business.
Somebody is making money out of the Alejandro Garnacho to Arsenal rumour. Whether it's a young journalist on a pay-per-click agreement or the website that's getting huge traffic - and a spike in revenue - as a result, somebody, somewhere, is making money off it.
Once you realise it's a business, you must start treating every rumour like it's someone's attempt to make money rather than a scoop from a real journalist like David Orsntein. And that's another thing. You can't avoid soundbites from people like Ornstein and Fabrizio Romano and 100s of others during this time of the year because, like the websites, they make extra money too. They are paid guests on Sky Sports, other football shows, podcasts etc. These outlets aren't paying for them directly; they're paying to be able to put their name on their headlines, which in turn leads to more traffic. Which leads to more money.
The summer transfer is a carousel of carnage, lies and attempts to profit and it's going to be such a long summer for us as Arsenal supporters if we're treating everything that the rumour mill churns out as fact.
Quote:Padre Pio
I remember checking for Reyes and Arshavin the same way.
Quote:mapleleafgooner
Who is Jonny Kipper?
Quote:regularjohn
I like this article. I wish I had had the time to write something similar myself.
They used to say that religion was the opium of the people, but now its definitely football.
Case in point, during covid, they very quickly realised that to improve public morale, they needed to get the football back on. I remember watching Hertha Berlin in an empty silent stadium on TNT sport and feeling that things were getting back to normal again. Of course, they werent. But it gave us all something to talk about again.
As evidenced by this forum, people are perfectly happy to talk about things that definitely wont happen, or almost certainly wont happen. Because it keeps us all busy and gives us something to do. And the media has tapped RIGHT into that. I'm as guilty as anyone in supporting this, because I drive a lot of miles each week (600 last week I think) and listen to Talk Sport. Since the season was pretty much over competitively by April, they have had to find things to talk about other than the football results. Literally HOURS if not DAYS were spent talking about Trent Alexander Arnold. Should he have been BOOED, or should he not have been BOOED. Then theres been probably about a solid month of debate about big Ange. Should he be SACKED, should he NOT be SACKED. Literally the same discussion over and over and over again. But thousands if not millions of people listen to it.
I'll always remember this kid on Arsenal TV about 8 years back, who used to stand there and be interviewed entirely seriously about who the next Arsenal manager would be. He was absolutely convinced it as going to be Allegri and spoke as if he had direct contacts within Juventus. He didnt, of course, he was a complete fantasist, and everything he said turned out to have not a single element of truth to it, but nobody called him out on it, he had his 15 minutes of fame and everyone was perfectly happy to watch him (well, not everyone, but you get my drift). There doesnt have to be any truth to a transfer rumour, it can be completely made up. All that matters is that people find it interesting enough to talk about, and fill the phone ins and internet forums. Its all very very odd really isnt it.
Quote:regularjohn
I like this article. I wish I had had the time to write something similar myself.
Quote:Flava
Where are we at with our transfer dealings at the moment:
Monitoring?
Assessing?
Initial talks?
Concrete talks?
Promising talks?
Keeping informed
Mulling over a bid?
Frozen talks?
Deal progressing?
What a load of nonsense it all is.
Quote:GS1Quote:Flava
Where are we at with our transfer dealings at the moment:
Monitoring?
Assessing?
Initial talks?
Concrete talks?
Promising talks?
Keeping informed
Mulling over a bid?
Frozen talks?
Deal progressing?
What a load of nonsense it all is.
What an utterly bizarre post given your comments 1 or 2 day's ago.
Quote:Flava
Where are we at with our transfer dealings at the moment:
Monitoring?
Assessing?
Initial talks?
Concrete talks?
Promising talks?
Keeping informed
Mulling over a bid?
Frozen talks?
Deal progressing?
What a load of nonsense it all is.
Quote:BG
We aren't a big club.
Quote:Flava
.......................we are a big club
Quote:Flava
Where are we at with our transfer dealings at the moment:
Monitoring?
Assessing?
Initial talks?
Concrete talks?
Promising talks?
Keeping informed
Mulling over a bid?
Frozen talks?
Deal progressing?
What a load of nonsense it all is.
Quote:Padre Pio
The season had started before Club signed Ozil. He was party of a clearance sale and never really fitted. Yes he some good games and scored some great goals but was hardly transformative.
Quote:Padre Pio
The season had started before Club signed Ozil. He was party of a clearance sale and never really fitted. Yes he some good games and scored some great goals but was hardly transformative.
Quote:mapleleafgoonerQuote:Flava
.......................we are a big club
Not the biggest but certainly not small..............
[www.transfermarkt.us]
#......Club.................................................Competition.................................Market Value
1......Real Madrid........................................Spain LaLiga.......................................โฌ1.33bn
2......Manchester City................................England Premier League...............โฌ1.32bn
3......Arsenal FC...........................................England Premier League...............โฌ1.09bn
4......FC Barcelona......................................Spain LaLiga.......................................โฌ1.07bn
5......Paris Saint-Germain.........................France Ligue 1...................................โฌ1.06bn
6......Chelsea FC..........................................England Premier League...............โฌ1.06bn
7......Bayern Munich.................................Germany Bundesliga.......................โฌ903.50m
8......Liverpool FC......................................England Premier League................โฌ867.50m
9......Tottenham Hotspur........................England Premier League................โฌ766.10m
10....Inter Milan.........................................Italy Serie A.........................................โฌ721.80m
Quote:Jonny Bravo
No, if I dont get at least 5 hits a day of Vitamin "Here we go" my summer is ruined.
Quote:GS1Quote:Merlion96
Nope.
Interesting views from you.
Thanks Merl.
