Should I Stay or Should I Go? : Brown


By Nathan Jackson
March 30 2008

With fans getting increasingly annoyed with his performances it is no surprise he's been nicknamed "Nat Clown" and he'll be extremely fortunate to earn a new contract this summer. Brown is one of several due to leave Sincil Bank unless he gets offered a new contract, which looks less and less likely with every passing day.

I've never been a fan of Nat Brown. I found it no coincidence that as soon as he reappeared in the first team last season our form suddenly went out of the window.

The game away at Hartlepool in March 2007 was a fine example of why Nat Brown is bad for this team. Hartlepool kept putting the ball into the box and Brown hoofed clear, Hartlepool picked it up and put another ball into the box, Brown hoofed it clear again. That was pretty much the story for 90 minutes until Brown then decided to clear a ball into the box with a handball a basketball team would have been proud of.

This season Brown has made mistake after mistake after mistake. It all started against Shrewsbury when instead of calmly controlling the ball and then clearing it, he tried to hit it first time and ended up scuffing it right into the path of a Shrewsbury player and the rest is history.

The vast majority of our defensive frailties are down to Nat Brown. For every good thing he does there is always two bad things just around the corner. Even his heading ability has now disappeared and you'd be hard push to find him making any positive contributions to games.

He appears to have no footballing brain and certainly no plan B. His method appears to be hoof and ask questions later. When he makes a mistake it usually leads to a goal and if we're going to have a squad capable of challenging for promotion then I see no place for Brown in our squad.

I would quite frankly be amazed if he if offered a new contract. Looking on the positive though, at least if he doesn't have a football club to play for then he can finally get his wrist sort.

What is your opinion? Do you think Brown should go or should he be offered a new deal? Post your opinion below.

Bookmark or share this story with:

Should I Stay or Should I Go? : Brown
Discussion started by theimps.tk (IP Logged), 30/03/2008 22:52
theimps.tk
theimps.tk
30/03/2008 22:52
Should I Stay or Should I Go? : Brown

MESSAGES->author
Kate Jackson
30/03/2008 22:52
Same principle as the Marriott thread.

Good Luck, Mr Gorsky


http://twitter.com/#!/katejackson84

http://www.katejackson84.blogspot.com

redclanger
!mpetuous
30/03/2008 22:53
No brainer - go!!

dannytheimp
dannytheimp
30/03/2008 23:01
Don't think anything can be said except time to go

MESSAGES->author
bigc_imp
30/03/2008 23:43
Never been a fan, he should go.

http://i242.photobucket.com/albums/ff106/bigc_imp/getwell.gif

heathimp
I Blame Paul Mayo
31/03/2008 07:51
had a good season last year i thought, but time to go.

MESSAGES->author
Aryan_imp
31/03/2008 07:58
Farsley Celtic or Guiseley awaits for The Clown! (Sm20)

http://i696.photobucket.com/albums/vv330/Aryanimp/666a.jpg

danrazzaq1
Dan_Baumber
31/03/2008 08:22
What are you all on about???? The most talented footballer we've ever had grinning smiley I'd play myself instead of him!

impsadaisy
impsadaisy
31/03/2008 08:45
yes its time for him to go, i thought he was improving last season, but unfortunately he didn’t carry on the improvement this season.

berksimp
berksimp
31/03/2008 08:56
Please go.

There were people on this board who raved about him, and week and week out complained about Mayo, when it should have been the other way round. Has been poor ever since he hurt his arm.

Tactically and positionally inept, all he can do is head and hoof a ball. Speed of thought 2/10, Pace 5/10, Skill level 4/10; sorry, not good enough.

MESSAGES->author
PoshImp
31/03/2008 08:58
Great goal at Barnet when we won 3-2 after being 2-0 down!

Otherwise, bye bye...

(Sm85)

CheshireImp
CheshireImp
31/03/2008 09:00
stay (Sm151)

robbie_imp
robbie_imp
31/03/2008 11:05
Gotta go, His Goal against Notts County away that year was class. But to me seems he hasn't got a clue about football positioning there are alot better out there.

bardneyimp
bardneyimp
31/03/2008 11:39
After a number of good seasons with us he now seems lost so i believe a change of club would do him good

nottinghamimp
nottinghamimp
31/03/2008 11:40
No option now, he has to go. I can see him going to Farsley with one of the others who should not have been with us this season.

randyimp
randyimp
31/03/2008 12:40
divs the lot of you!wether nat brown stays or goes the last thing people need to be doing is totally destroying his or anybodys confidence with only a few games to go.im sure after fridays game with mk win or lose the kids will get destroyed by the so called city faithful and they can also sit on the bench until you lot hound them out.

Red Imp
Red Imp
31/03/2008 12:48
He wasn't too bad in midfield but defensively, his positional sense is woeful. Good in the air, but on the deck, not the best.

I think Jacko will get rid of him at the end of the season.

Hasn't he got another year to run on his contract?

randyimp
randyimp
31/03/2008 13:04
yes im sure he has, so all the more reason for people to lay off!

mightyimp1
mightyimp1
31/03/2008 13:25
sorry nat - got to go mate.
just not good enough and every time he gets nearthe ball you fear the worst. makes too many errors.
thing is though you have to ask yourself why has he been a starting regular of recent weeks, makes me think he may be offered a new deal. i'd rather have moses playing who i saw in the stand at peterborough

MESSAGES->author
Aryan_imp
31/03/2008 13:41
Quote:
randyimp
yes im sure he has, so all the more reason for people to lay off!

God help us, oh well with Hand & Torpey gone, a suitable candidate to vent our spleen at when things go wrong (Sm14)

http://i696.photobucket.com/albums/vv330/Aryanimp/666a.jpg

Markus Naslund
Markus Naslund
31/03/2008 15:10
When he played in midfield under Keith I think he suited that role. He was just a spoiler doing the crappy bits and peices - but he also contributed some goals.

His early games at centre half I thought were encouraging. Since when he has been inconsistent and prone to a howler here and there. But lets be honest, he is not alone.

He's one of the players we love to hate which I find distasteful as mob mentality is rarely constructive and too often is unthinking. As ever I don't think he is anything like as bad as is often portrayed on here.

That said, I think he should be released.

My biggest problem with him stems from the opening day of the season when he gave Phil Watt a volley of verbal after one of Shrewsbury's goals. Watt had made a mistake (and a big one!!) but was a young lad, making his debut in a team that was being over run. I would like to have seen more of Watt. I think his confidence was shredded after that game and I don't think Nat Brown helped. At times a right bollocking is needed. But there are times when quiet encouragement is needed. For me, Nat's judgement on that day was as bad as any of his mistimed tackles...

true_imp
true_imp
31/03/2008 19:10
what about the other players? yes he has done some mistakes but most the team have. i think if he had a decent and experienced defender alongside him, he could prove everyone wrong. he needs telling what to do at times, when that happens, he can play very well. lay off him, we arent going to get better by shredding all the players confidence, bloody hell.

True Imp

http://i167.photobucket.com/albums/u126/sizp/2003.png
[

Pickyimp
pickyimp
01/04/2008 01:08
Old 50p head has to go. You never know where the ball is gonna go when he has headed it!!

The Goob, The Orginal Car Pooling Solution:
Sponsored By Subway..... Eat Fresh

impish chap
impish chap
02/04/2008 23:50
Got to be released imo,had a good spell at centre half when he came back from injury oct/nov last season but poor positioning,marking and distribution well,sums the whole defence up i suppose!!!Big keith will welcome him at macc in another ex imps reunion!!!

Goto Page: 12Next
Current Page: of 2
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net