By Gordon Thomson
February 15 2004
Airdrie managed to snatch a draw from the jaws of victory in this Valentines Day clash devoid of that 'loving feeling'. A stroll in the park turned into yet another New Broomfield farce as Airdrie's misfiring forwards failed to capitalise on almost total dominance....
Sandy Stewart fielded the exact same team as last week's promising 'turned corner' win at Methil. A full starting home debut for Christie, Lovering and Willie McLaren. Dumbarton had a strong looking defence with the experience of perennial 'heel' Craig McEwan, Jamie McKinstry and giant stopper Neil Collins. Up front, of course, they had former Diamond, Paul Ronald, recently released by Airdrie on the transfer window. AIRDRIE UTD
Airdrie made a whirlwind start with Alan Gow firing a right footed shot on target in the first couple of minutes that Dumbarton's goalie did well to get a hand to. The early fizz faded a little as the game settled into the usual long distance prompting and prodding of the two teams sussing each other out. Dumbarton offered little in an attacking sense but Airdrie found it tough to break through the solid Dumbarton back line. Gow and Coyle were finding central defender Neil Collins especially hard to beat in any aerial jousts, whilst the midfield were not getting the passing game going under pressure. Airdrie did make the breakthrough thanks to wingers McLaren and Varielle. McLaren chipped a delightful cross to the back post for the Frenchman to easily head home from one yard out.
Despite having the one goal advantage a second is now the priority but for Airdrie it just doesn't seem that easy. Coyle was one on one with the keeper and seemed to be brought down. I wasn't convinced, but the reaction from the players and the manager would suggest that Dumbarton got off lightly. The last ten minutes of the first half promised there could be more to come with Gow suddenly coming to life, Vareille and McLaren looking promising. However the frayed nerves of this long, desperate winter still foremost in the minds of the fans. We need to play better and build on the lead.
Second half Airdrie bombarded Dumbarton. Collins and McKinstry stood firm in their defence but further out they were taking it in turns to sink the boot. Midfielder Donald was twice booked for fouls on Docherty leaving them with ten men for the last 20 minutes, and down our left flank they were taking turns to try flattening wee McLaren out of the game. McEwan in particular was getting away with murder. Turned inside out by McLaren, he very obviously snapped attempting to bully the kid with his intimidating manner, aided and abetted by a few of his mates including the no 7 who was only spoken to for one horrible, pre-meditated lunge. More later. Before the horrid finale Airdrie had several chances to double the lead. Coyle, Docherty and Vareille all had efforts from a variety of sources, but hapless ref Toner did Dumbarton two massive favours by clearly ignoring two seperate penalty claims. One may have been ball to arm but the second one with about 15 minutes was so obvious my wife could have seen it. At this stage Airdrie weren't playing at all well but were still pretty much in control. Dumbarton had improved after committing their subs, in particular the blond right winger Rodgers. He fired in a powerful long range shot that McGeown almost misjudged, just to remind us we were still in the game...
Airdrie seemed to be panicing with about quarter of an hour left. The team were holding on but seemed to be toiling for the second goal. Stewart reacted to the crowd's impatience by hauling off the dangerous but off the boil Gow for Glancy, and unsurprisingly the thread was starting to unravel. In my opinion the whole club's nerve started to go. We had a one goal lead, were holding out albeit misfiring in places, but the fans, players and management could all be said to have their collective knickers in a knot. Dumbarton fed off this and turned the game nasty. Roberts came on for Coyle with ten minutes left as we pushed for the killer second. McLaren was firing on all cylinders and running rampant down the left but without protection from the hapless ref Kevin Toner Dumbarton nullified our main threat with McEwan's bullying. Stewart took off McLaren presumably for his own protection as hapless ref Toner wasn't capable. Stewart, Kenny Black and a couple of the players looked as if they wanted to hit McEwan themselves as things got out of hands and then BANG!! Three minutes left and Mark Roberts is sent clear in the inside left channel. Vareille is with him taking position on the edge of the box it's two against one. All Roberts had to do was square to Varielle but instead the scourge of Airdrie fans managed to do was tamely, no pathetically, pass to the isolated defender. He in turn launced a counter attack the ended in Mark McGeown racing in a kamikaze fashion from his goal line to attempt an interception on Rodgers down our left but he missed, McGowan sheparded Rodgers wide anyway, but the Dumbarton winger could easily fire home into the now empty net. Yet again we managed to shoot ourselves in the foot in Buster Keaton fashion when the three points were there for the taking. When it came to bottle ours crashed.
| McGeown | Sold the goal | 5/10 |
| Christie | Lurched about the right back zone all day without contributing as much as last week. | 5/10 |
| McManus | Commanding presence again. Looks a cut above most of his teammates. Will be missed when his two match ban starts next week. | 8/10 |
| McGowan | Steady. | 7/10 |
| Lovering | Fitted in well defensively. | 7/10 |
| Vareille | Hitting form again down the right flank, and a goalscoring threat. | 7/10 |
| Docherty | A bit better than last week he did keep battling away. | 6/10 |
| Dunn | Not is best game. Too many misplaced passes for my liking. | 6/10 |
| McLaren | Had a quietish first half but was always a danger with his pace, skill and intelligence. Was left unprotected by the ref when he was having lumps kicked out of him. Our best attacking player by a mile. | 8/10 |
| Coyle | Still quick upstairs and over two yards but he was lost for pace on a few occasions. However he is at his best in the six yard box but we don't get the ball in there enough. IMO he works too hard outside the box. | 6/10 |
| Gow | Too stop start. He had a lot of good moments tempered by misplaced passes, tame shots and taking on one man too many. | 6/10 |
| s. Glancy (for Gow with about 15 mins left) | Didn't really get into the game. | n/a |
| s. Roberts (for Coyle with about 10 mins left) | Why bother. Another abject misery of a performance. Stephen King couldn't dream up a bigger nightmare than this guy. | n/a |
| M.Wilson (for McLaren with about 5 mins left) | Only on for a few minutes however his only noticeable touch was a bad pass. OUCH! | n/a |
| Manager: Sandy Stewart | Couldn't really be faulted for the first 75 minutes. The team kept it tight, created chances and had three penalty claims turned down, at least one stone waller. He was let down by some bad finishing too, and how can he legislate for Roberts' poor pass that led to the goal, or McGeown's rush of blood? I wasn't happy with the subsitutions, I'd have kept it as it was but there you go. | n/a |
