Dumbarton (2) v. Airdrie (0)

By Gordon Thomson
November 16 2003

Airdrie have been on a slump since the last 15 minutes of the recent Challengue Cup final. The injuries to McManus, Gow, Sandy Stewart and Scott Wilson have rocked us badly and confidence has been truly shattered in recent weeks. We had a chance to get back on track at Dumbarton but....

Why, oh why, oh why? I've been a fan of Sandy Stewart and have every faith that he'll succeed as a manager but today even I, his biggest and most vocal fan, was scratching my head again. Never mind the game ending substitutions, what about him choosing that same midfield again? We have a confidence crisis running through our team but for me it started badly by choosing that same midfield as last weeks dour draw. We've only hit a decent run of form this season with Marvyn Wilson and David Dunn in centre midfield. When they play there we have fluidity, passing, invention and style. When we have Doc in there we're obvious, no passing options, we start playing long to our midget strikers and the defence is exposed. Docherty was also providing some quality from wide right, never mind the fact that Dunn absolutely stinks as a wing back. We could easily have played Docherty on the right, Wilson on the left with Marv and Dunn in centre midfield. Could it have been any worse than what we've had to suffer in the past couple of weeks? It didn't help that Gow was again missing but that meant that crowd favourite Martin Glancy got a chance to start again.

AIRDRIE UTD

McGeown
Scott Wilson, Stewart, McGowan
W.Wilson, M. Wilson, Docherty, Dunn
Vareille, McKeown, Glancy.

Check out Bob Dalzell's photo gallery of the game. Remember his photos are copyright controlled.

Even the drubbing by Morton didn't seem as bad as today's game. Against Morton we dominated for 20 minutes before our injury ravaged defence crumbled. Today we just didn't seem capable of sticking it to Gemmell and Rankin's boys. Fair enough Docherty hit the bar in the first half, but a couple of decent moves by Glancy and McKeown apart we lacked invention. Our day was summed up late in the first half when Vareille, sent clear and bearing down on the goalie in a one against one situation, checked out of his run when the ball was playable. And Dumbarton's Nigerian, Didier Agathe-alike, forward was looking menacing.

Nothing about our drab, lifeless performance changed after the break and it was no surprise that we went a goal down. Obidile worked a situation well on the right and his cross evaded a bemused Willie Wilson for Dillon to head home. Immediately Glancy was replaced by Willie MacLaren, a move that was greeted with howls of disgust. Not for MacLaren. Moments later Vareille was replaced by the unlikely Paul Ronald and cue the abuse aimed at the player boss. Dumbarton made it two in almost identical fashion before a late rally from McKeown and MacLaren petered out.

That performance was about as miserable as I can remember. Too many players weren't worth the admission money. From a goalie that flaps at crosses and panics with a ball at his feet to defenders that aren't tackling, to midfielders that can't pass, to wingers that can't cross, to strikers that can't strike, we are a dishevelled looking mob that could do with the week off to regroup, maybe take advantage of the new transfer legislation, and hopefully come back refreshed. We need to get the midfield four sorted out immediately. Marvyn's form has dipped, Dunn is worse than a man missing, Docherty is less effective in the middle. Three problems that can be sorted by a reshuffle. Scott Wilson needs to be worked with on the training ground. Why can someone become so bad overnight? What about the Willie Wilson situation,and the goalie? I think the strikers are the least of the problem just now as there are goals in Varielle, Dosser, Gow and even Roberts but a lot of that is dependant on the rest of the team getting sorted out. I'm still confident that Sandy can and will get it sorted out. I just hope that he gets a couple of better quality players to work with as soon as possible before the promotion dream fizzles out.

McGeown His horrific form continues... 4/10
Willie Wilson One excellent clearance excepted, not good enough. 4/10
Scott Wilson Awful 4/10
Stewart As a player he was fine, indeed tried in vain to push his team on. 6/10
McGowan A bit of an improvement from him 5/10
Dunn Absolutely hopeless. Couldn't have been worse if he tried. Never a wingback and he can't defend. 0/10
Docherty Apart from some threatening first half runs, and that effort off the bar, he wasn't good. Almost disappeared after the break. 4/10
Marvyn Wilson Worked hard but his game is falling apart again. I can't think of a professional player who passes the ball so badly and cannot shoot. 4/10
Glancy I thought he was playing pretty well. Was always having to drop deep but he worked hard and was unlucky to go off. 6/10
Vareille Looking dispirited. If only he had Dosser's attitude? 5/10
McKeown Our only bright spot. Dosser worked extremely hard but had little support. Just wish his teammates would figure that he's not seven foot tall. 7/10
s. MacLaren(c.65mins for Glancy) Took a while to get going but linked well with Dosser. Unlucky not to score near the end. n/a
Ronald (c70mins for Vareille) Hopeless n/a

Bookmark or share this story with: