By Gordon Thomson
December 2 2004
Airdrie sufferred a jarring setback at Stairs Park as their recent good run came shuddering to a halt. It's a defeat that takes the wind out of any promotion thinking and now makes the New Years Day fixture at Dumbarton all the more crucial.
Airdrie were still without injured midfielder and had Paul Harvey in his place while Kenny Brannigan sat out the game thanks to his suspension from the Stenhousemuir game. David McGuire was missing from the match too presumably a victim of the flu bug that was reported in the press so Alan Gow took his place up front.
It's fair to say that our preformance was miserable in this one. Our team were dwarfed by the Stranraer players in key areas of the pitch and their game plan was well suited to the awful pitch that was made even more sticky by a prematch downpour. That's not to say we were without the odd chances here and there. Indeed Airdrie had two very good chances to take an early lead. Firstly Jerome blazed a shot over when it looked easier to score, then minutes later Alan Gow looked culpable as he snatched a shot when he had more time than he thought. As usual when we're profligate we get punished and Stranraer drove the stake in with a double blow soon after. Firstly they took the lead with a Michael Moore header from a corner after quarter of an hour. Moore, not the tallest of strikers, managed to glance on the corner from the edge of the six yard box as our goalie and Paul Armstrong surrounded him.
Minutes later Armstrong wasted a throw in from the halfway line and Stranraer broke forward. As the Stranraer player drove into the box it appeared that either Vella or Stewart had scythed the player down, Vella was certainly vocal in his protests, and the penalty was awarded for Ian Harty to slot home.
Two nil down and over an hour left it wasn't beyond Airdrie to stage a comeback. There were too many players not performing well on the day though and any attempts to get back in the game were futile. Gow, starting his first game for a while, showed a lot of nice touches and turns but would beat the first man then run straight into the second almost like he was running on quicksand. Harvey played central midfield but looked incapable of winning a tackle or completing tow passes in a row. I was heckled at one point for booing him. I'm normally supportive in a critical kind of way when things are going bad but that guy was in the kind of form that drives me crazy. Paul Armstrong wasn't having much success on the left again. He just doesn't seem comfortable there although I personally think he's maturing into a fantastic player for us in the same way Sandy and Paul Jack did ten or eleven years ago. Many fans constantly ask why Armstrong is played out of position like that when Liam McVey, who didn't look the worst player in the world, can't get a game. One can only presume that there is something deeper there.
The second half was a long drawn out frustrating non event for us. When Sandy finally put us out of our misery and replaced Harvey, to a chorus of boos of which I wasn't one this time, with Ronald, it looked again like we could find the extra gear to get back into it. Presumably like me he had seen that despite his best efforts Dosser McKeown wasn't winning that many high balls so McKeown dropped back into midfield though in fairness Ronaldo didn't fare much better up front. McKeown though was a revelation in the middle constantly driving the team forward and it's fair to say he was unlucky on several occassions not to single handedly drag us back into the game.
Stranraer had a couple of really good chances to get back into it. Vella with a neat flick on and Sandy misjudging a long ball gave the home side two one v. one situations that McGeown in goals did remarkably well to save but in the end even his heroics couldn't inspire the comeback.
Lessons will be learned from this game. For example Paul Harvey should never be playing central midfield. He doesn't have the strength for it. At his peak he was a winger or withdrawn striker. He might still be able to unlock a defence but not from there. Armstrong at left back? He can and will provide the bite in midfield or preferably at right back where he belongs. Gow has failed to impress as a starter yet again and as happens with a good player McGuire looked a better player when he wasn't there. Maybe some will stop criticising him now and encourage him to get even better. Ultimately though it would have been a different matter if Jerome had just buried that easy chance early on!!!!!!
| McGeown | Could've done better at first goal and looked dwarved at some corners but performed some heroics later on to keep us in it. | 6/10 |
| Vella | Didn't win that many headers for such a big guy and may have been culpable with the penalty. Steadied a bit later on. | 5/10 |
| Stewart | Similar to Vellaa he had a bit of an off day too. | 5/10 |
| McGowan | Typical McGowan performance. More suited to the conditions than most at the slippery surface enhanced his tackling range. | 7/10 |
| W.Wilson | Another energetic performance. At least he's a trier. Didn't have much luck against their 7' tall winger but he did try. | 6/10 |
| Harvey | Out of position and it clearly shows. Lacked the physique and tenacity for the role he was asked to play. Another dreadful display I'm afraid. | 2/10 |
| M.Wilson | Up against it in midfield against to ferocious competitors and without much help. | 6/10 |
| Armstrong | Tried gamefully to drive us on from left back but not having much success. | 6/10 |
| Vareille | Tried and tried but nothing came off. Needs to bury his easy chances. | 5/10 |
| McKeown | One of our few shining lights. Our own Wayne Rooney never knows when he's beat and particularly from midfield later on looked capable with a display of aggression, tenacity and skill. | 8/10 |
| Gow | Poor display again. His first couple of touches always looked good but on the porridgey surface he got easily bogged down | 5/10 |
| s. Ronald | Came on for Harvey but never got into the game | 3/10 |
| s. Gardner | Replaced Gowser but never settled. | 2/10 |
