Carbone 'Ellis has no ambition'


Carbone

By The Fear
February 17 2003

"Ellis has no ambition. He's the boss and spends the money, but he's always bought a mediocre level of player, and Villa can't compete for the League title like that." So Benito Carbone has come out and said what he thinks of the set up at Villa. Although many accuse him of being a mercenary, some of his points look fair to me and it is interesting to get the insight from players. I only wish others, especially Ugo, Southgate, Boateng, Yorke and Merson would give their impressions of this club. Not so the fans can get more angry and boo them more, but to give us some insight into what exactly is the problem at Villa.

Tony Morley said that players in his day would have walked to Villa Park to play and were proud to put on the shirt. It was considered a privilege to play for us and yet now many of the players either want out or consider Villa to be a great stepping stone, you always look at class players like Mellberg and wonder just how long it may be before a 'bigger' club comes in for him. Or how long it will take for him to come to the conclusion that Villa are drifting. Their careers are short and the real winners in the game (the sort of players we want to keep) don't want to drift, they want to win honours. If Villa can't provide the platform for them to do so, why would they want to commit their futures to us?

These days it seems to mean much less to wear the famous claret and blue. Even Schmeichel*, who has mixed with the best, mentioned the lack of ambition from the players and the fact that some players (and I have witnessed some!) out on the town after defeats. Surely it isn't too much to ask for these highly paid athletes to look after themselves during the season and to conduct themselves properly, as is befitting a club like ours, after all, they are paid enough.

If the fans are gutted by the results (it affects our whole week) then they should care about the results too, they are meant to be our hero's fighting for the fans. I haven't seen much fight of late! They have shown a few times this year that they are not really up for a battle......examples? Blues, WBA (away) and Blackburn (FA). They had very little heart or bottle and certainly didn't look like they were proud to wear our great badge.

However Carbone has backed up one of my arguments. The apathy on the pitch has filtered down from the top, we have no real direction. One week we are told we are aiming for the Champions League, the next we are a selling club. Then Europe is the ambition, then the accountant tells us we can't compete with Manchester or Arsenal......blinking heck, we can't even compete with Charlton or Southampton at the moment. The league does not lie, I don't care what anyone says, we are 12th because we are average. Should of's and could of's don't mean diddly squat.

Carbone says "Torino and Napoli were both chasing me, but I chose Villa because the manager really wanted me there. I got on superbly with him, he was my salvation. " and the article in the Times reminds us that his time at Villa 'reaped tangible dividends with Villa reaching the FA Cup final of 2000....and Carbone revelled in the roaming role given to him.

However, it all turned sour when Villa decided not to take him on a permanent deal. Reports at the time suggested he wanted too much money, but didn't he almost single handedly get us to the FA Cup? JG was trying to add a bit of flair to a very negative and boring side and maybe a few more sparks like him would have balanced the defensive and attacking problems. However Carbone 'remains convinced that Gregory's hands were tied by the habitual interference of Doug Ellis, the chairman. "Ellis has no ambition. He's the boss and spends the money, but he's always bought a mediocre level of player, and Villa can't compete for the League title like that."

Now some would boo any player for daring to suggest that, but I feel that he is only saying what the fans, the players who have left, and the last 3 or 4 managers have already discovered, we are drifting; and if we don't stop soon....................

Quotes from timesonline.co.uk.

*I couldn't find the reference for the Schmeichel story, but got the thread of the topic from listman.net.org

Bookmark or share this story with:

 

Aston Villa latest threads