Username
Password
Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?

The next Bully?
By Tom Bason
November 21 2008
On Tuesday night, a little piece of history was made at Bramall Lane as three Wolves players appeared together for England U-21’s. On the face of it, this is brilliant for the club, and maybe in the future, Richard Stearman, Michael Kightly and Sylvan Ebanks-Blake will progress to play together for the full team. Look a little closer though, and maybe it’s not as wonderful as it first seemed.

All of these players were bought.  While this says volumes about the club’s current transfer policy, how good would it have felt for us fans had they progressed through our youth system?  Think about how much pride Wolves fans got seeing Matt Murray and Lee Naylor pulling on U-21 shirts, or hearing that Wayne Hennessey has kept a clean sheet for Wales, or even now when Jo Lescott plays for England or Robbie Keane scores for Ireland.

I don’t know about you, but 2006/07 season, Mick McCarthy’s first in charge, is one of the best in recent memory.  A young team, playing vibrant, attacking football finishing in the playoffs when many expected a relegation battle following the departures of Glenn Hoddle, Lescott, Naylor and Kenny Miller the previous summer.  For me, one of the best things about that season is the way that Mick was prepared to play our youngsters.  No fewer than nine academy graduates pulled on the Old Gold shirt that season, many for the first time.  It was thrilling to watch, and for the first time in many a season, there was a feeling that the club had a real future.

Now though, our future appears to be coming from other clubs.  Is this an indication of a general reluctance in England now to bring through their own blood, preferring instead to buy it ready made?  Arsenal are the most obvious example, taking advantage of stricter employment laws in foreign countries, for example in Spain where a player cannot sign a professional contract until his 18th birthday.  The likes of Cesc Fabregas would still be in Spain if it were not for this rule.  Liverpool haven’t brought a regular first-teamer through their youth system since a young Steven Gerrard burst onto the scene 10 years ago (boy that makes me feel old), and even Manchester United, with their famous youth system have turned to buying from abroad.

We are nearly halfway through this season, and so far we have not played one outfield youth product.  Yes, you read that right- every outfield player who has featured in the League so far has been bought.  Admittedly, most of these have been bought in relatively cheaply, but surely it is even cheaper to not have to pay for them in the first place.  So where have all the youth players gone?  Is it a coincidence or a sign of something altogether more worrying that our two brightest prospects in recent years, Mark Davies and Lewis Gobern have spent so much time on the treatment table?  Injuries have definitely played a part, but cannot be used as the full answer.  Is there a general dislike by the management team to play them?  Dan Jones and Mark Little, who both impressed two years ago have scarcely played a game between them in the past 18 months, both being loaned out to lower League clubs.

And, maybe it’s time for us fans to take a look in the mirror.  Maybe we are perfect examples of the supposed English trait of building people up just to knock them down.  Look at the way that Keith Andrews, our youngest ever captain and Leon Clarke, who at one point was being dubbed as the ‘next Steve Bull’ were treated towards the end of their Molineux careers, and to a lesser extent Lee Naylor.  More recently, Stephen Gleeson was the next ‘big prospect’.  After supposedly interesting Barcelona following a youth tournament, and a string of excellent performances while on loan at Stockport County, Wolves fans had high hopes, which could lead to massive disappointment if he doesn’t fulfil the hype.  Of course fans are going to get excited about youngsters, there is nothing better than seeing one of our own out on the pitch giving their all, but maybe these expectations become burdens and need to more reserved.

So what of the next generation, the likes of the Bennett brothers, Ashley Hemmings and the precocious young talent of Zele Ismail?  Given our current squad, can anyone really see any of these getting enough opportunities to prove that they are good enough when every point is vital and potentially the difference between playing Premiership and Championship football the next season?  Maybe this is the problem with the English game.  With unprecedented (and some may say obscene) amounts of money in the game now, clubs cannot afford to gamble.  Every point is vital, especially in the Premiership where each place is worth an extra half a million pounds.  Clubs cannot afford to plan for the long term, quick fixes are the order of the day, and if this means bringing in foreigners ahead of blooding youngsters, then managers have to do this.

So, back to Wolves.  Maybe the conveyor belt just isn’t churning out the quality that it has in the past.  Or, are we in the midst of a downward spiral?  If the young players are not getting chances, maybe future generations will be less willing to join us at a young age, leading to less quality in the future.  Another observation is the difference in quality between our goalkeepers and outfield players.  Our youth system has produced three of the Championship’s best goalkeepers, in fact the last time a none youth team goalkeeper started a League game for us was Jan Butz in April 2007 and before that, Stephan Postma twelve months earlier.  I do not know what the problem is, if there is even a problem, it would just be really nice for the fans to see one or two home-grown players out there.

View a Printer Friendly version of this Story.

Bookmark or share this story with:

Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: Wolves (IP Logged)
Date: 21/11/2008 00:00

Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: Mick McCarthy for Prime Minister (IP Logged)
Date: 21/11/2008 02:32

Really enjoyable read, and food for thought no less!

I think someone switched the conveyor belt off for two years because it seems that we've got talented youngsters, they're just not near ready for first team football, being in a title challenge probably hasn't helped their chances and getting promoted may make it even more difficult for them to break through. If Mick doesn't think they're ready he's better off letting Gleeson, Hughes etc. get experience elsewhere and at least when they come back they'll be fit, relatively confident and a good option to have. On the flip side if they can't perform in the Championship at a time when we've good a squad as good as the league and lesser ambitions then I find it hard to believe older academy graduates like Gleeson/Jones/Davies will ever get into a Premiership Wolves team.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2008:11:21:02:34:56 by Mick McCarthy for Prime Minister.

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: seanb (IP Logged)
Date: 21/11/2008 12:16

A good read. I think it is the best I have seen from you. But which current club's successful youth development policy should serve as an example to the rest? I'm struggling to come up with one. Man City were looking good but then they got bought.

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: AlexMacca (IP Logged)
Date: 21/11/2008 12:40

Wolves have been producing a lot of good youngsters over the years. But your lucky if one in twenty youth players progress to the first team squad. Thats just the harsh reality of it. Wolves are one of the better clubs for nuturing young talent, but if their not good enough for the first team, or not experienced enough, they won't play.

Players like Gleeson, Bennett, Davies etc should all be playing games at the moment to help their development. But we've got a strong squad of professionals standing in their way, so the best bet is sending them on loan. Mick obviously thinks they have a future at Wolves because otherwise he would be looking to offload them. He's not afraid of cutting his losses.

Fingers crossed our youngsters come back better players and fight for a first team place next season. Premiership or not, these lads our important to our future.

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: Wolf Like Me (IP Logged)
Date: 21/11/2008 16:20

Seanb, how about Middlesbrough? Plenty of young players coming through there?

http://imagegen.last.fm/iTunesFIXED/recenttracks/10/toomb.gif
aka toomb

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: Risca TM (IP Logged)
Date: 22/11/2008 10:18

Very enjoyable article. Do you think the lack of reserve team football in a proper league has anything to do with it? Perhaps they struggle to consistently impress over a period of time, while missing the chance to build a harder competitive edge.

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: Square Pegs Round Holes (IP Logged)
Date: 22/11/2008 10:44

True, but we have brought in other teams youth players very very cheaply instead. Which could also mean that we have got a better player for less than the cost of his upkeep in the academy etc. So all in all I really don't care if they are our young players or somebody else's as long as they are still OURS.

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: Old Wulf (IP Logged)
Date: 22/11/2008 11:37

A very good article Tom.

It's unfortunate that Lewis Gobern and Mark Davies have suffered long term injuries as I think they would certainly have been given the opportunity to impress in the last two seasons. This season is a different matter - we now have a very competitive squad and I think Mick is doing the right thing in getting the young lads, who are showing potential, the experience they need in the lower divisions.

http://www.newsoftheworld.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00008/chris1_516x350_8679a.jpg

Re: Where Have All The Good Kids Gone?
Posted by: Wolf Like Me (IP Logged)
Date: 23/11/2008 22:37

I just can't see when they are going to be given a chance when every point is so vital.

And this isn't just a Wolves problem, there are very few top players being brought through by top clubs anymore

http://imagegen.last.fm/iTunesFIXED/recenttracks/10/toomb.gif
aka toomb

Goto Thread: PreviousNext
Goto: Forum ListMessage ListLog In

SPORTS SPREAD BETTING

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net